How do you tell if someones engine has
suffered a loss of water and overheated, thus causing permanent damage - especially when
they tell you it hasnt?
Temperature indicator strips or, second best because they are not so
easy to fit, metal melting tabs. The UK happens to have the worlds leading
manufacturer of temperature strips: Thermographic Measurements Ltd. of Connahs Quay,
North Wales, which makes products which are distributed to the remanufacturing world by
Dave Hadley Engineering Ltd. The company has been manufacturing temperature sensitive
labels for more than 25 years and claims to have 90% or more of the UK market.
Thermographics "Thermax" strips are used very widely in
the automotive world, and similar devices can also be found checking temperatures at which
chocolate is distributed and sold, ensuring that electronic components do not overheat,
and showing the temperature distribution on the surface of gas turbines. Formula 1 racing
is also a major user.
Russell Booth, General Manager of Thermographic says the company has
supplied temperature strips to all the F1 teams at one time or another to check when
recommended operating conditions for engines, engine management units, radiators and a
host of other parts are being exceeded. Though perhaps the most interesting uses of strips
will never come to light, as engine and vehicle manufacturers use them to help iron-out
design faults on new products.
But how do they work? The self-adhesive strips each contain several
small white paper squares, each impregnated with a thin layer of an organic,
microcrystalline wax-based chemical which turns black at its set temperature. The strips
most commonly used in automotive engine applications contain squares which turn at 88, 99,
110 and 121ºC. In an engine, the most commonly asked question is this: has this engine
ever dried-out or not? A strip firmly stuck onto the core plug or elsewhere will provide
the answer - if the 110ºC square is black then the engine has overheated at some time
since the strip was fitted.
These strips are irreversible, that is any black areas stay black,
preserving the evidence of overheating until someone chooses to look. They are also
impervious to oil and water.
Dave Hadley says: "With temperature strips, Im basically
selling insurance. A strip can mean the difference between a successful insurance claim
and one that is turned down. And if a strip can save you the cost of one replacement
engine a year, it has been well worth it."
And how well do they perform? Thermographic say their strips are
accurate to within plus or minus 1ºC below 100ºC and to within plus or minus 1% above
that. To prove it, Russell Booth showed ER&R how they are tested. Strips are stuck on
to a silver block which is heated electrically. The tester notes the temperature at which
each part of the strip begins to and completes turning black - this is usually between 0.5
and 1ºC - and the mean of these two readings should match the strip ratings.
Temperature is measured using an embedded thermocouple to accurately
record the temperature of the plate. The whole process is carried out in an ISO 9000
environment on testing equipment which is accredited and recalibrated every six months by
independent certification authority NAMAS. The tests we witnessed were spot-on.
Thermographic manufactures an enormous number - 32 million a year - of
temperature labels and a huge range of specially-designed products covering temperatures
from -30 to +1270ºC. Products include labels for which the color change is reversible and
irreversible, devices based on thermochromic liquid crystals and a series of paints, inks
and crayons which change color according to temperature.
Oddly, there simply isnt a chemical ready to turn black at every
point on the thermometer, although Thermographic is forever developing and testing new
ones, and thus the use of squares around 10ºC apart on the automotive strips.
For automotive uses temperatures trips are a very cheap and easy-to-use
method of keeping tabs on an engine in use. Strips are small enough that they can even be
hidden in an inaccessible location to ensure they are not tampered with.